Get in touch with us at Maureen.Lowe@pittsfordcookieco.com
Online Pre-Orders
🥎 Cookies for a Cause: Help Strike Out ALS! You're in the right spot. Order ALS Celebration Cookies or make a straight donation below — 100% of proceeds go directly to the ALS Association on behalf of the Pittsford Mendon Varsity Softball team.
What's Baking Now
Our current cookie lineup, available for porch pickup.
CINNAMON ROLL COOKIE
Swirls of cinnamon filling, drizzled with vanilla glaze. Worth falling for. Single: $3 Half-Dozen: $15 Dozen: $27
$3.00
Almond Croissant Cookies
A soft buttery cookie with homemade almond paste tucked inside, topped with sliced almonds and a heavy dusting of powdered sugar. All the flavor of an almond croissant — in cookie form.
$3.00
Chewy Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
The perfect balance of chewy middle and crisp edges. Made with golden raisins — plumper, sweeter, and a serious upgrade from the average oatmeal raisin cookie.
$3.00
Crumb Cake Cookie
Tastes just like a slice of NYC-style crumb cake. Soft buttery cookie base, thick cinnamon crumb topping baked on, generous dusting of powdered sugar — exactly the way it should be.
$3.00
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Made with browned butter and loaded with mini chocolate chips. Soft, deeply flavorful, and chocolate in every single bite.
$3.00
ALS Fundraiser (Pittsford-Mendon Vikings)
Cookies for a Cause: Help Strike Out ALS🥎
The Pittsford Mendon Varsity Softball team is playing in the 2026 Strikeout Lou Gehrig's Disease Classic on May 16th, and 100% of proceeds from ALS Celebration Cookie orders and ALS Donations go directly to the ALS Association on their behalf. Want to add a donation to your order? Check the "ALS Donation" option below — pick any amount. Or skip the cookies entirely (we can let it slide this time) and donate directly.
ALS & Mendon Vikings Softball Celebration Cookie
Our signature cookie, in two custom sprinkle blends — half in ALS awareness colors, half in Mendon Vikings team colors. 100% of proceeds go directly to the ALS Association on behalf of the Pittsford Mendon Varsity Softball team. Qty: Half Dozen
$16.00
ALS Donation
Add a donation to your cookie order — or skip the cookies entirely (we'd forgive you this once). 100% goes directly to the ALS Association on behalf of the Pittsford Mendon Varsity Softball team.
$5.00
Pickup is Saturday, May 16 from 10 am - 1 pm. Come anytime during the pickup window. The 15-minute slots are just a system requirement that's not customizable.